Well, that was a genuine surprise.
I decided that if I was going to see I Play Rocky (which seemed intriguing on the basis of the trailer), I had better see the original Rocky first.
I would have been too young to see it when it first came out, and I have spent the ensuing half-century filing it under “macho boxing movie starring that guy from Rambo who ruined Judge Dredd, which I probably wouldn’t like.”
But settling down to watch it for the first time on Netflix, I was surprised to discover that...
!!!!it’s brilliant!!!!. (*)
I mean, genuinely. Not Bridget Jones’ Diary or Back to Black level brilliant— “not really my kind of thing, but I enjoyed it a lot more than I expected to.” I am talking Godfather Part II level brilliant: "obviously one of the greatest movies ever made."
Why did no one tell me this? And does this mean I will have to go and see that other Great Big Boxing Movie at some point? I was labouring under the misconception that Rocky was a populist reworking of Raging Bull, but it’s almost literally the other way round.
It’s very much of its time. In a weird way, it kept reminding me of (say) Annie Hall: Woody Allen and Diane Keaton exchanging sidewalk witticisms which the audience is deemed to be overhearing. But that only amounts to me noticing that a quasi-documentary, semi-realistic style was in vogue . I Play Rocky makes the point that in 1976, the steady-cam was new technology: Rocky was only the third film to make use of it.
In I Play Rocky (hereafter I-Play), the fictionalised Stallone says that Rocky is not a boxing movie, but a movie about a character who happens to be a boxer. That is partly true, although considering it is not really a movie about boxing, a lot of punch-bags, sides of beef, and people get hit. Very hard. But the film really does come across as a character study.
It is entirely believable that we’re watching the first completed screenplay by a raw but talented writer. The individual scenes — and particularly the dialogue — are uniformly breathtaking; envisaged by someone who has an eye for real human behaviour, but also a true sense of the iconic and mythic. The actual plot seems occasionally to clunk. The scene in which world-champion Creed finds that he has no opponent and sets up a fight with an unknown as a publicity stunt didn’t ring entirely true. Possibly a you-shall-go-to-the-ball fairy tale requires a degree of artifice? or possibly there is an intentional clash of register between the scenes in the Creed camp and the fly-on-the-wall realism of Rocky’s life? Creed consciously presents himself as something of a cartoon character.
Rocky loses. I really didn’t see that coming. In fact, the film is a string of moments that don’t go anywhere: the script would never have got through Christopher Vogler or Blake Snyder’s sorting hat. Rocky has a goldfish and terrapins in his apartment because…he just does. He works as a debt collector for a mob loan shark, which leads to… nothing in particular. When he gets his big break, he quits smoking and drinking, gets up early in the morning, runs for five miles and works out in the gym, and generally acts like a serious athlete who wants to win his match. (I-Play is similarly practical about writing a script being a hard slog.)
We wait in vain for the wrinkle. Will Rocky blow the expense money or his fighting fee on drugs or drink or lavishing presents on his terminally nerdy girlfriend? Will he lose confidence at the last minute? Will someone offer him even more money to throw the fight? No, no, and no. He does realise that he can’t possibly win and will be satisfied to “go the distance” — stay on his feet until the last round. But there is no cheating, no match-fixing, no temptation to sell out.
There is an alternative universe in which Ronald Reagan played the lead in Casablanca. It is hard to believe that anyone ever thought that Burt Reynolds or Clint Eastwood could have starred in Rocky. (James Caan, who had played Sonny in The Godfather, was a less obviously silly suggestion.) I do wonder if the young Stallone could have been quite so much like movie Rocky as I-Play paints him. Watching the two films back-to-back, it is easy to get the two characters mixed up: was Rocky Balboa reduced to taking parts in porn movies on the basis of his dick size rather than his acting abilities? Was it Sasha or Adriana who worked in a pet shop? It is entirely believable (and documented) that Stallone wrote the part for himself and wouldn’t allow anyone else to play it, even if the unrefusable offers that the studio make in the making-of movie may be somewhat exaggerated for dramatic effect.
Stallone (despite the obvious Brando comparisons) doesn’t seem to have studied so-called “method” acting, but he is clearly a gifted improviser who gets inside the role. According to I-Play, the astonishing scene in which he berates Mickey (who runs his boxing gym) and then asks him (in an iconic long shot) to be his manager was more or less extemporised on the spot. Cleverly, the turning-point scene in the movie is also the turning-point scene in the making-of movie. Penguins apart, Burgess Meredith was a very established and respectable actor who took a part in a low-budget long-shot movie. A lot of people really did believe in the underdog script.
It is a very writerly film. When Rocky isn’t punching things, he is having one-sided conversations with similarly inarticulate characters. His big confrontation with Mickey takes place through a bathroom door, and he has a meaningful conversation with his girlfriend Adriana while she’s locked in her bedroom. (“I ain’t never talked to a door, you know”.) A first-person novel turned into a sports film; and an action movie conducted as a series of monologues; we’re in the head of a very clever man who can’t quite get his words to mean what he wants them to and comes out with a kind of poetry instead. (“She fills gaps. I got gaps, she got gaps, together we fill gaps.”) If the thought is “Rocky can only communicate with his fists” it isn’t forced down our throats too severely.
I-Play largely takes all this for granted. There are some beats I don’t entirely buy: a few scenes in which it is obviously condensing days or weeks into single moments. I understand it to be true that the professional fight arranger left the movie at an early stage; but I doubt that he walked out on Stallone five minutes after arriving (but after conveniently giving a talk which explains how Stallone’s approach to boxing differed from the normal Hollywood style). I believe it is true that the film was suggested by a real-life fight between Mohammed Ali and, er, another boxer — in which the challenger lost the match, but won a moral victory by knocking the unbeatable champ down in an early round. But the scene in which Sly watches the fight in the pub and then rushes home to write the script in three days flat is the kind of thing which always happens in this kind of movie. It is also very much the kind of thing that writers like to say about their work. Stan Lee made up a story about a spider crawling over his writing desk to explain where Spider-Man came from some years after the actual events. But the central structural idea — that the writer had to train almost as hard as the character to get to the point where he could convincingly play a boxer in a movie — is clearly true.
Like Rocky itself, I-Play finishes rather earlier than you might expect it to: Rocky in the seconds after the fight, I-Play part way through the first screening. A lot of movies that are based on a true story like to show photos or clips of the real-life prototypes over the closing credits, but I-Play smartly winds up the story with archive footage of Stallone accepting the Oscar for best movie of 1976. Definitely stick around for the pleasingly meta post-credits.
Sometimes you see a film of a book with a reputation and wonder what all the shouting was about. Some people on the internet take it for granted that if a movie is well regarded, it must be a case of what they call the emperor’s new clothes. When I first saw Citizen Kane, as a student, I immediately said that I could see why it was the greatest movie of all time, but I think I admired all the classics on general principles because I had such excellent taste. Citizen Kane is, in fact, a very good film. Half a century late to the party, I would instantly put Rocky on my list of the top ten great movies; and unlike The Godfather, it doesn’t wear its greatness on its sleeve.
During the last Olympics, I watched a few minutes of a boxing match on the TV, and it isn’t nearly as exciting as in the movies: it’s all people with their fists up dancing around a ring trying to poke a punch in the right place. Similarly, fencing is nothing like The Princess Bride. And if people really get as beaten up as Rocky and Creed did, I am still not at all sure it ought to be allowed.
Virginia Woolf said that Middlemarch was the only English novel written for grown-up people. I don’t know if she ever saw Rocky. But I had a strong feeling that this was, in the best sense, an adult movie; a movie for people with an interest in characters and landscapes and other ways of life, and are prepared to spend some time finding out where the story is going. I agree with whoever it was who said that at times it feels like a science fiction movie, with Philadelphia coming across as an alien landscape.
Which, of course, draws our attention to an historical fact. The first modern blockbuster, Jaws, came out in 1975. Rocky was 1976. And in 1977, a little science fiction movie by George Lucas carried all before it. Two roads diverge; and we took the one which put all subsequent drama in thrall to a false theory of mythology and plot construction. I have written a thing or two about the sci-fi movie, and I am certainly not going to say that it infantilised Hollywood or reduced all subsequent movies to mere spectacle. But I do think it led to a world in which there could never again be a movie in which the terrapins were irrelevant.